How to Date a Guy That’s Not Your Type

Ready to Attract the Love You Deserve?

Claim your free, personalized Love Strategy Session now and see if Executive Love Coaching can lead you to the lasting love you deserve.

Schedule Your Free Love Strategy Session

You’ve been dating the same type of guy for what feels like forever. So, how’s that working out for you? As we often say, “If what you’re doing worked, it would have worked by now.” A part of you might cling to the idea that “the heart wants what the heart wants,” or “I know what I like,” believing you can’t imagine anything else. Yet, there’s also that nagging feeling that your “picker” might be broken.

Why Your “Type” Isn’t Working

Let’s face it: if you consistently pick the wrong partners, you’re setting yourself up for disappointment. It’s like trying to build a successful company with the wrong employees – it’s just not going to happen. Taking ownership of your choices is crucial because this aspect of your dating life is truly within your control.

Often, your “type” is largely superficial. We’re talking about general attractiveness, perceived success, material possessions, height, specific facial hair, tattoos, or that “bad boy” look. The problem is, when you chase these traits, you’re emphasizing chemistry over character and authentic compatibility. Many of these preferences aren’t even truly yours but rather reflect societal norms and advertising ideals of masculinity and success.

Editor’s note: Ready to attract love with a proven strategy? Watch this free video to learn the 7 powerful steps

Sometimes, your “type” is based on psychological or interpersonal qualities – maybe you’re drawn to the quiet, standoffish type, or the “cool/popular/alpha” guy who often masks insecurity. What’s more, your “type” often gets set at the wrong time: early in your dating life when you were still figuring out who you were. Why should what you were into back then, when you might have been willing to accept less, still hold true today?

You might also be drawn to “project partners” – guys who give you something to do or work on, allowing you to feel superior or needed. And what feels familiar isn’t always good. Psychologists call this cognitive entrenchment: a mental rigidity where you’re so fixed in your thinking patterns that you struggle to accept new perspectives. If your past experiences were negative, that “toxic familiarity” can feel like safety, even when it’s harmful. You need to recast your “type” as toxic familiarity.

Why You’re a “Bad Picker”

There are a couple of key reasons why your picker might be off. First, you’re not really picking at all. You’re using bad (or no) strategy, perhaps even being a little lazy, leaving it all up to him or to fate. While this sounds romantic, it’s a recipe for disaster. When you wing it and take a haphazard approach, you should expect haphazard results.

Second, you’re too focused on his feelings, not yours. You’re basing your emotions on how he feels about you or the attention he gives you, rather than on your own genuine connection and compatibility.

How to Do Better

So, how can you improve your dating game?

  1. Focus on Yourself. To find the right person, you have to be the right person. Research shows that when you don’t know yourself well or have low self-concept clarity, you struggle to determine a good match, making it harder to rule out incompatible partners. You’re also more likely to date incompatible individuals.

  2. Break the Illusion of Scarcity & Similarity. Don’t fall for the belief that your “type” is the only one for you, or that all guys are the same. This “all the same” belief usually comes from a lack of experience. Many clients have an “aha” moment when they realize, after meeting enough people, that not all guys are like their ex.

  3. Look for “Nourishing Novelty.” Instead of toxic familiarity, embrace a “type” that is fluid and expanding. Your old “type” is just an arbitrary rule, a form of self-handicapping or misguided self-protection. To get unstuck, reset your range. Purposefully go beyond your usual choices. Try a “20% time” approach to dating: make 1 out of every 5 dates a trial with someone a little different. You might surprise yourself!

  4. Don’t Follow the Herd. Avoid the partners everyone else goes for – the outwardly attractive, outgoing, smooth talkers. Instead, look for “hidden value” or those partners most people overlook. This could be guys with lackluster profile pictures, less flashy bios, or those who are a little nervous and not as bold.

  5. Default to Yes. What would make dating easier? Fewer rules! Embrace a spirit of exploration and experimentation. You don’t know until you try. If it’s not a “hell NO,” it’s a “yes.” Get more experience and see firsthand that all guys aren’t the same.

What do you think? Share your thoughts below...

Subscribe
Notify of

31 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
6 months ago

I never thought I’d spend this much time laughing at chili puns, but here we are! This collection is fire — pun intended. As someone who runs a food blog, I know how tough it is to come up with clever content that keeps readers engaged. These spicy wordplays would be perfect for any taco night post or hot sauce promo. If anyone’s looking to spice up their humor game, these chili puns are the way to go. Definitely bookmarking this for future content inspiration. Hilarious and creative work — keep the flavor coming!

6 months ago

I’ve been searching for bold and hilarious Dirty Fantasy Football Team Names and this list totally delivered! It’s the perfect combo of cleverness and cheeky humor — ideal for leagues that don’t take themselves too seriously. I especially appreciate how the names balance being edgy without crossing the line. These are the kind of names that’ll get a reaction in any draft room. I’m using one of these for my team this season and already getting laughs. If you want to bring spice and smack talk to your fantasy league, this is the list to check out!

6 months ago

Finding creative and fun trio group chat names can be surprisingly hard — but this list made it so easy! Whether you’re in a group with your besties, siblings, or coworkers, these name ideas perfectly capture the vibe of a tight-knit trio. I loved the mix of funny, sassy, and pop-culture-inspired options. It’s the perfect way to personalize your group chat and make it feel even more connected. I already picked one for our group and we’re obsessed! If you’re part of a power trio looking to upgrade your group name, this list is the perfect place to start.

6 months ago

As a huge anime and manga fan, I’ve been searching for the best place to read Jujutsu Kaisen manga online, and this site totally delivered. The layout is clean, the pages load fast, and the translations are on point. I love how easy it is to keep track of chapters without any annoying pop-ups or interruptions. For anyone who’s hooked on Gojo, Sukuna, or Yuji’s journey, this is hands down one of the best online options available. I’ll definitely be recommending this to fellow fans. So glad I found a reliable place for JJK updates!

6 months ago

Encontré por fin una página confiable para consultar todo sobre fone iebem. Me encantó lo fácil que es navegar, encontrar recibos de pago, y acceder a información oficial sin complicaciones. Para los trabajadores de la educación en México, esta plataforma es esencial. Recomiendo guardar el sitio en favoritos porque siempre está actualizado y tiene guías claras. Además, explican muy bien cómo entrar, cómo recuperar tu contraseña y cómo imprimir comprobantes. Sin duda, si trabajas en el sistema educativo y necesitas consultar tu nómina, este sitio con información sobre fone iebem es el mejor lugar para comenzar.

6 months ago

So glad I found this article about snowball kiss! It seems like everyone on social media is using new terms lately, and I’ve seen this one pop up a lot on TikTok and Twitter. I really liked how this post didn’t just define it but also gave some context and background about how the phrase became popular. For anyone who’s heard the phrase in conversation or online and didn’t quite get it — this clears it up perfectly. Great breakdown of internet slang. More people need to read this before jumping to conclusions about what snowball kiss means!

6 months ago

I’ve been using this Aldi weekly ad page for a while now and it’s become part of my grocery routine. It’s super convenient to see what’s on sale before heading to the store. The early previews give me a head start on finding the best deals — especially for fresh produce, meat, and special buy items. It’s also fun to browse the Aldi Finds section each week and discover unique seasonal products. For anyone who wants to make the most out of their Aldi trips, this Aldi weekly ad page is a total game-changer.

6 months ago

This really challenges the way we think about attraction and compatibility. Just like in gaming, where sticking to one ‘type’ limits your experience, expanding your range can lead to unexpected wins. Speaking of variety, I recently explored a different kind of action-strategy with Mod Stick War Legacy — surprisingly fun and tactical

weas7
6 months ago

I always thought I had a “type” until I realized it wasn’t working. Dating someone different opened up a whole new vibe—new interests, better convos, more laughs. I met someone on kos date who didn’t fit my usual mold at all, and it turned out to be the healthiest connection I’ve had. Be open—you might just find someone better than you imagined.

Frank Whitley
6 months ago

This article makes a great point about how sticking to a specific ‘type’ can limit your chances of finding real compatibility. It’s a helpful reminder to prioritize character over chemistry and to stay open-minded—you might be surprised by who turns out to be the Curve Rush Game right match.

¡Un artículo realmente revelador! Aprendí mucho desde tu perspectiva y aprecio la claridad con la que explicas todo.

5 months ago

This article very well points out that being stuck on just a “type” can lead you to the wrong partner again and again. Real connections happen when you date with clarity and honesty. I recently read up on “Looking Loud” where it is explained how game-changing it can be to state your needs directly and confidently. It gave me new perspectives Loud Looking in Dating

Rhonda Jennings
5 months ago

Such a refreshing perspective! Sometimes stepping outside of our usual ‘type’ really opens the door to healthier and more meaningful connections. Great reminder to focus on character over chemistry. Snow Rider 3D

4 months ago

I appreciate how your posts address readers’ needs with clear solutions.  If you are interested in penguin publishers, feel free to explore trusted professionals who can help shape your ideas into polished content.

wacky flip
4 months ago

Wacky Flip Game gives you the freedom to move however you want—no rules, just fun wacky flip!

4 months ago

It’s so true that sticking to the same “type” rarely leads to lasting happiness. Real growth comes when we step out of our comfort zones and give someone different a chance. Just like exploring new tools such as MI portal fone sep helps us discover smarter ways to connect, being open in love can reveal possibilities we never imagined. Sometimes, the best match isn’t the one we thought we wanted, but the one we actually need.

4 months ago

This article makes a strong point about how our “type” can sometimes limit us from finding the right person. It reminds me of how learning with an Online Quran Teacher works—you may think you already know the style of teacher that fits you, but sometimes the best guidance comes from someone outside of your expectations. Just like in relationships, growth happens when we step out of our comfort zone and open ourselves to new possibilities.

2 months ago

It’s funny how this article about dating outside your usual “type” reminds me of trying new strategies in gaming. Sometimes, we keep choosing the same kind of partner or playstyle just because it feels familiar — but growth happens when we explore something different. Just like dating someone who surprises you, trying a new strategy game like Stick War: Legacy can totally shift your mindset. It challenges you to plan, adapt, and think beyond your comfort zone. And if you love experimenting with new tactics and unlimited possibilities, check out Stick War Legacy unlimited all — it’s a fun way… Read more »

2 months ago

Reading this made me realize how dating and gaming actually have something in common — both require strategy, patience, and a willingness to try something different. When you keep choosing the same “type,” it’s like playing the same level in Stick War: Legacy with the same tactics and expecting new results. Sometimes you have to experiment — explore new strategies, test different builds, or even check out the Stick War Legacy mod menu to see what options open up when you play with flexibility and creativity. That’s when things start to get really interesting — in both love and games.

2 months ago

I genuinely enjoyed reviewing your work, similar to how players uncover valuable insights and excitement when engaging with the kslottery.com.

2 months ago

I truly appreciated going through your work, much like how participants find valuable insights and excitement while exploring results and experiences with the Ohio Lottery.

1 month ago

MiPortal Fone promueve el autoaprendizaje mediante contenido educativo organizado y fácil de usar. Es una plataforma confiable que impulsa el desarrollo del conocimiento, las habilidades y  https://miportalfoneesep.com.mx/

Your insights are always engaging and make readers think—looking forward to your next post! Also, recent Culver’s visitors can take the tellculvers.com survey to give feedback and get a chance to win rewards.

29 days ago

Faisal Movers is one of Pakistan’s leading intercity bus services,
 known for providing safe, comfortable, and reliable travel across 
the country. The company operates a wide network connecting 
major cities such as Lahore, Karachi, Islamabad, Multan,
 Faisalabad, and many northern areas. Faisal Movers offers
 modern buses with air-conditioning, comfortable seating, 
onboard entertainment, and professional staff to ensure a
 pleasant journey for passengers. Read More

29 days ago

PPP Family ID (Parivar Pehchan Patra) is a unique identification system for families that helps the government maintain accurate family records. 
It links all family members under one ID to ensure transparent and efficient delivery of welfare schemes and services. 
Through the PPP Family ID, citizens can easily access benefits like pensions, scholarships, and subsidies. 
It also helps reduce duplication and ensures that government support reaches the right people. https://pppfamilyiid.com/

21 days ago

This advice on dating outside your usual type is thoughtful and encouraging. Trying new perspectives can be refreshing, just like exploring a Minecraft mudded version for a different gameplay experience.

11 days ago
Reply to  minecraft

You’ve done a really fantastic job. heartfelt appreciation for it. Customers must have a recent Dunkin’ receipt with a survey code in order to take the Dunkinrunonyou.

10 days ago

The game Anomalous Coffee Machine creates a coherent yet anxious world in which any interaction with the coffee machine might instantly alter the situation for the player. Players interactively manage occurrences in the shop, ordering and rearranging elements to deal with anomalous happenings and escape the pandemonium.

<a href=”https://deltaexecutoor.com/”>delta apk</a> también conocido como Delta X, es una herramienta avanzada para ejecutar scripts personalizados en Roblox, mejorando la experiencia de juego con características como teletransportación y trucos de velocidad. Es compatible con Android, iOS y PC, y no requiere un sistema de llaves, permitiendo un acceso instantáneo. Utiliza el motor de ejecución de scripts Aorom, compatible con el 92% de UNC, lo que minimiza el riesgo de detección.

<a href=”https://pattachita.com/”>patta chitta online</a>  linked to Aadhaar, is crucial for property transactions, dispute resolution, and ownership verification. The portal also offers services like Patta transfer applications and document verification, streamlining land management for both urban and rural residents.

12 hours ago

<a href=”https://theveduapp.com/”>vedu</a>  for students’ education. Use the Veda movies APK play to view their most liked lesson, furthermore, I am searching for viewing cricket matches. Due to the Vedu APK big quality sequel, I view many series, the World Cup, and other competitions on it.

Other articles you may like...

7 Ways to Spot Red Flags Before It's Too Late

7 Ways to Spot MAJOR Red Flags Before It’s Too Late

5 Signs A Guy Doesn't Like You

5 Signs a Guy Doesn’t Like You

Video thumbnail for youtube video a4qc2zxlibm

Men’s Dating Coach Spills His Secrets